2004-07-22steel
Commission character assessment
EVD-005
Source dependency
Circular sourcing
Repetition is not corroboration. A blog that cites a book that cites a news story that restates a Commission paragraph is one observation, not four. Official and alternative claims are both checked.
Circular sourcing (demonstration)
Repetition is not corroboration. EVD-032 is a fixture: quality 0.63, zeros on contemporaneity, corroboration, chain of custody.
2003–2006unknown
Later news restatement
Derivative of public Commission language.
2006unknown
Book citing the news
Directed cycles
No closed citation loops in the current graph. That is not a finding of independence — it only means no A→B→A loop is stored yet.
Multi-hop chains
A cites B cites C. Each extra hop is a chance that independence was lost.
- EVD-203 → EVD-208 → EVD-107 → EVD-106
Robinson cites the 2023 free-fall paper / Korsgaard flashes. · 2023 paper is an explicit challenge to NIST's Stage 1 characterisation of the same free-fall measurement. · FAQ elaborates NCSTAR 1A collapse timing.
- EVD-150 → EVD-107 → EVD-106
AE911 petition cites free-fall among other NIST-critical points. · FAQ elaborates NCSTAR 1A collapse timing.
- EVD-208 → EVD-107 → EVD-106
2023 paper is an explicit challenge to NIST's Stage 1 characterisation of the same free-fall measurement. · FAQ elaborates NCSTAR 1A collapse timing.
- EVD-212 → EVD-107 → EVD-106
2012 Chandler chapter uses NIST's free-fall stage against NIST. · FAQ elaborates NCSTAR 1A collapse timing.
- EVD-203 → EVD-208 → EVD-107
Robinson cites the 2023 free-fall paper / Korsgaard flashes. · 2023 paper is an explicit challenge to NIST's Stage 1 characterisation of the same free-fall measurement.
- EVD-203 → EVD-208 → EVD-106
Robinson cites the 2023 free-fall paper / Korsgaard flashes. · Challenges NCSTAR 1A global-collapse narrative.
- EVD-203 → EVD-123 → EVD-106
Robinson 2024 rests on Hulsey 2020. · Hulsey is an explicit challenge to NIST 1A.
- EVD-400 → EVD-404 → EVD-105
Wikipedia external links include the 2006 State Department page. · State Department page restates NIST/Commission; not independent.
- EVD-400 → EVD-403 → EVD-105
Wikipedia external links include Popular Mechanics. · Popular Mechanics is derivative of public NIST/Commission records.
- EVD-400 → EVD-402 → EVD-105
Wikipedia engineering publications list points at Eagar 2001. · Eagar 2001 is earlier than NIST; later NCSTAR 1 is the fuller official model, not a citation of Eagar.
Flagged one-hop citations
Tertiary blog ultimately restates Commission language.
Clarification is derivative of the PBS clip.
MacQueen compilation is derivative of FDNY oral histories.
2006 article derivative of the same oral histories.
Robinson 2024 rests on Harrit et al. 2009 — not independent of it.
Timeline aggregator points at the same San Diego facilitation record; not a new primary.
Toronto ch.12 is a hearing restatement of Harrit 2009.
Zarembka is derivative of Poteshman 2006.
Popular Mechanics is derivative of public NIST/Commission records.
State Department page restates NIST/Commission; not independent.